The Ivy Awards are the gold standard for outstanding food service operations. I thought I’d take a peek at the websites of this year’s restaurant winners: Alinea (Chicago), Bartolotta Ristorante di Mare (Las Vegas), Hotel Healdsburg (California) and Per Se (New York). The two other recipients, the University of Massachusetts, Amherst and the Presbyterian Hospital of Plano, Texas were less suitable for the comparison. So, in alphabetical order:

Alinea
A long download time (for what?) built up my expectations, but the website gave me little. The site is uncluttered and a tad sexy, but there’s no sense that actual human beings work there or that those humans prepare and serve food.

I suppose they prefer I learn more about them from online reviews. I’m a seasoned fine diner, but that doesn’t mean I wouldn’t like to get an idea of the types of dishes they serve. Nice of them to drop their address on the bottom of each page, though I nearly missed it.

Bartolotta
As far as I can tell, Wynn Las Vegas aggregates their many fine restaurants on their hotel website, so each restaurant in the empire displays in its own section, while the chef-heads behind the other establishments scroll quietly below. While a few of Bartolotta’s details are overlooked in this somewhat cluttered presentation, the imagery – of the chef, the food, the stunning setting – gives the website visitor a nice sense of the place.

Hotel Healdsburg
A classy presentation, again complicated by the fact that this restaurant is part of a hotel and spa. Nevertheless, both the Hotel Healdsburg site and brand have a warm elegance that helps provide a feel for the place. All of the restaurant information is there, and it’s obvious a visit to the Hotel Healdsburg is far more than just going out to eat.

Per Se
There is no denying that this is a lovely entry screen, yet why does my first interaction with Per Se have to relate to the Flash player version in my web browser? (I have Flash 9, thank you).

Anyway, I expect from the caliber and reputation of this restaurant that their website would be cool and controlled. The concept of the site appears to be of a visitor peeking through a door, as if walking by the restaurant kitchen door when it was just closing. Kind of a romantic sentiment. However, I find the navigation functionally overwrought and the overall feel is dark, heavy and a bit of a turnoff. Very little of their soul is coming through.
For all my rants, I am developing a Best Restaurant Website List. Got a nomination? Feel free to share it with me at: sara@successfulrestaurantwebsites.com.